THE DANIELS
REVIEW.

The Mall The Mall The Mall

For American teenagers in the 80s, 90s and early 2000s, the shopping mall was a social universe. Food court gossip, wandering endless indoor promenades, and awkward first dates at the multiplex were defining rituals of adolescence, immortalized in countless teen films and television shows.

The Mall The Mall The Mall, written by Philip Kenner and directed by James Wyrwicz, takes this familiar setting and spins it into something delightfully absurd. A group of teenagers embark on a heroic quest through their local mall to recover missing Buffy the Vampire Slayer merchandise while battling an evil Hot Topic shop assistant.

With a heightened comedic sensibility, a punchy early 2000s soundtrack, and video game style battle sequences, the dynamic cast including Ellena Eshraghi, Mahayla Laurence, Trent M. Williams, Mia Wurgaft and Mikey Fiocco keeps the audience entertained throughout the 75 minute performance at The Tank NYC. The performers lean fully into the show’s exaggerated tone, appearing like larger-than-life versions of your favorite Nickelodeon characters. Fiocco’s villainous Hot Topic employee is a particular highlight and he gleefully embraces the melodrama of the role.

Kenner’s script is also a playful reflection on early 2000s American pop culture. References to Pokémon, Avril Lavigne’s Sk8er Boi, and the intimidatingly cool retail environments of stores like Hollister create an instantly recognizable world. Beneath the zany comedy, the show quietly explores familiar teenage anxieties including peer pressure, identity, and the universal desire to fit in.

One of the standout moments is a Pokémon inspired dance number towards the end of the show, which prompted nostalgic smiles and laughter from the audience.

With minimal scenery or props, the production relies heavily on the audience’s imagination to conjure the sprawling mall setting. The intimate space at The Tank suits the show’s energetic style, but the concept feels like it could grow further with a larger staging. A more expansive set or immersive design might allow the mall environment to come fully alive and heighten the sense of adventure.

Overall, The Mall The Mall The Mall is a lively and affectionate tribute to early 2000s mall culture. Its blend of absurd humor, nostalgic references and energetic performances makes for an enjoyable evening, even if the production occasionally feels constrained by its intimate staging. With a larger canvas, this playful mall adventure could become even more memorable.

The Mall The Mall The Mall runs until March 22nd at The Tank NYC. More information and tickets available here: https://thetanknyc.org/calendar-1/2026/2/28/the-mall-the-mall-the-mall

We are giving this 3 out 5 D's

Tickets / more information ↗

Filed underOff-Off-Broadway3 D's

Share this review

WhatsAppFacebookX

Send to a friend, share with your audience, or save the link for later.

Keep exploring

Related reviews

Honor Shmonor

*Honor Shmonor* began with swords, shouting and two medieval heroes charging into a witch hunt with absolute confidence that they were doing the right thing. It was a very funny setup, but Atticus Orsborn’s dark comedy soon started poking holes in that confidence, turning a playful fantasy adventure into a smart look at power, prejudice and the excuses people use to justify cruelty.

What a World! What a World!

There is never a point during *What a World! What a World!* where it feels content to do just one thing. Eric Marlin’s play, directed by Ilana Khanin at The Tank, mixes classic Hollywood, rehearsal room drama, experimental movement, drag, and social commentary into a production that is constantly changing direction. The result is an ambitious show that kept us interested throughout, even if it was occasionally a little confusing.

Love Story

There is something about a night at The Tank when it is completely full that immediately changes the temperature of a show. *Love Story* opened to that kind of room. A Thursday night that somehow felt like a weekend. Loud, warm, expectant. The house team deserve real credit here because they do not just welcome you, they actively build momentum. Their opening spiel is not filler. It is part rally, part mission statement, part celebration of artists, and it genuinely prepares the audience to meet

More from the archive →

Reviews in your inbox

Get our weekly email with the latest theater and performing arts reviews.